geosbooks's profile picture

geosbooks 's review for:

2.0

This book was fine honestly until the end. I didn’t love the characters but they were alright. The writing had beautiful moments but I wanted that same quality of writing throughout. My main issue however has to do with its portrayal of “seasickness”.

TW from here for depression/suicide

Throughout this novel they refer to seasickness, despair and a lack of hope about the future of humanity under the sea. It’s essentially depression and it and suicide because of it are brought up quite a few time. I didn’t really have any problems with its portrayal until the very end of the book. At the end the protagonist Leyla “realizes” that the sickness isn’t linked to the water, it’s essentially caused by the government spreading fear. The illness isn’t inevitable, people could have been saved if so much fear didn’t exist.

It felt very dismissive of the actual experiences of people with depression and suicidal ideation. It very much sounds like the people who claim that positive thinking or paying less attention to negative media will cure depression. I think that if you’re going to frequently bring up what is essentially depression (it’s not even really a metaphor for depression, it is depression) you need to have a sensitivity reader who knows about the experiences of depression. Any sensitivity reader with experience with depression and suicide would have immediately picked up on the issue of saying the seasickness is caused by fear. Reading the paragraph where Leyla realizes this stung and would be more harmful if I were doing worse when I read that.

Please if you want to respect the experiences of people with depression and the topic of suicide, don’t read this book. It came so close to addressing problems with access to mental health supports and addressing stressors like housing and access to therapy and then took a hard turn at the end of the book.