Take a photo of a barcode or cover
calarco 's review for:
The Reason I Jump: The Inner Voice of a Thirteen-Year-Old Boy with Autism
by Naoki Higashida
Initially I picked this book up due to a desire better understand the subject matter, and I saw the initial positive reviews. The story of Naoki Higashida writing this book as a 13-year-old wanting to share his experiences with autism, was a compelling enough reason in and of itself. In this sense, I would say that there is genuinely good information shared as pertains to this perspective. Higashida is a remarkable young man whose experience is important and needs to be shared.
That said, because of the position of the young author, I feel that a great deal of liberty was likely taken by the editor (and later on by the translators) when conveying Higashida’s words. I think this was done with nothing but the best intentions, and not done so with any nefarious desire to spread malicious falsehoods. Given my lack of knowledge on this topic, I did seek out other perspectives and saw these sentiments echoed in Sally Tisdale’s NYT review .
I’m still not sure of how I should feel about this book. On the one hand, I feel like there is an important perspective here. On the other hand, I feel like this perspective may have been inadvertently altered through the lens of the adults involved in publishing the work. It was a nagging feeling I could not ignore as I flipped from page to page. If anyone else has any thoughts, I’d genuinely like to know your own two cents on this one.
That said, because of the position of the young author, I feel that a great deal of liberty was likely taken by the editor (and later on by the translators) when conveying Higashida’s words. I think this was done with nothing but the best intentions, and not done so with any nefarious desire to spread malicious falsehoods. Given my lack of knowledge on this topic, I did seek out other perspectives and saw these sentiments echoed in Sally Tisdale’s NYT review .
I’m still not sure of how I should feel about this book. On the one hand, I feel like there is an important perspective here. On the other hand, I feel like this perspective may have been inadvertently altered through the lens of the adults involved in publishing the work. It was a nagging feeling I could not ignore as I flipped from page to page. If anyone else has any thoughts, I’d genuinely like to know your own two cents on this one.