illustrated_librarian's profile picture

illustrated_librarian 's review for:

Jackal by Erin E. Adams
4.0
dark mysterious tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

Welcome to Johnstown, Pennsylvania. If you see something... no you didn't. 

As a Black woman, Liz Rocher doesn't have the fondest memories of her predominantly white hometown, but she's reluctantly returning for her best friend's wedding. On the day of the wedding the couple's daughter Caroline disappears into the woods. A frantic search ensues, but Liz sees a pattern: a summer night, a Black girl murdered. Her hometown is hiding something, and Liz isn't letting it stay in the shadows any longer. 

Adams blends detective thriller and horror elements with social commentary on violence against Black women in America. A series of young Black women have gone missing in the woods over the years and yet the town always manages to dismiss it: the girls are characterised as runaways, unruly kids who died of animal attacks, exposure, or some other freak accident. 

Liz has grown up hearing folktales of the 'man and his shadow' lurking in the woods. If you hear something call your name in the night or you think you see something? Keep your head down. Pay it no mind. 

She sees a connection between the evil in the woods and the missing girls, but who can she trust? Who will believe her? Adams ratchets up the tension by highlighting the disparity Black women face being believed, being looked for, being safe in the very places they call home. She fills Johnstown with believable, human characters each suspicious in their own way so Liz is always destabilised, second-guessing herself until the last. 

What stopped this being a five star for me was the choppy, short sentences Adams favours paired with the tendency for jumping from topic to topic quickly within one paragraph. Though I recognise this was mimicking Liz's stressed, flighty thoughts, it broke the immersion for me and could be hard to follow. But the pages do fly by, and Adams makes sure you're on the edge of your seat.

This is a story about monsters, the supernatural and the shockingly mundane. It's about how violence can be explosive but also insidious: neglecting a neighbourhood, turning a blind eye, keeping quiet to keep your white self comfortable above all else.