A review by wulvaen
Children of Dune by Frank Herbert

challenging dark inspiring mysterious reflective sad slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.5

I shall start off this review by simply saying:
What the fuck???

The philosophy in this book is some of the best in the series, the buildup was quite good....until Leto started rolling around in the sand with Sandtrouts and
making himself turn into a wormboi
and somehow knowing how to do it, and then we got good old-fashioned
brother marrying his sister.


The portrayal of
Paul
was excellent for a good while, It felt like he had grown wise in his
self-exile
and had come to despise the corruption of the world
he sought to bring into fruition
in the first 2 books and preached out against
his own creation
in hopes of tearing it down and
his children
fixing things...but no. As soon as he meets Leto, he becomes a dumb dumb and
sacrifices himself
in a shitty way in equivalence of stupidity of how Dune 1 had the Baron killed off-screen by the 4 year old side character.

Ghanima seemed pretty interesting there for a while too, the twins were at their strongest character-wise when they were together,
the second they seperated is when they went down hill
. Leto became so self-indulgent and spouted out philosophy in rapid-fire that it became exhausting, despite throwing some interesting notions and questions at the reader, I believe such things should come in moderation. And then Ghanima simply got dumber and more emotional and one-dimensional, she got the Chani treatment but with more rage.

Dont get me started on this
wormboi
business. What the actual fuck Frank Herbert. What the actual fuck. Whatever you were smoking during the creation of this book, I beg of you to cut that shit out and have a cup of tea instead. Like sure I get the symbolism and how the Freman will immediately
accept him as God
as they already worship Shai-Hulud, the Maker, the Worms, and so now that
Leto has worm powers they think him Shai-Hulud.
I get it. Congrats, it fits into the mythos, but why the hell did you go down this route? Have you learned nothing from the first book? You can't make your main character extremely powerful without any consequences or a delicate balance they must contend with!

I can't believe I'm about to say this, but I'm moving onto God Emperor of Dune, wish me luck 👀