You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
thecaptainsquarters 's review for:
City of Windows
by Robert Pobi
Ahoy there me mateys! I received this sci-fi thriller eARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. So here be me honest musings . . .
I picked up this book based on two ideas: 1) that NYC is stuck in an apocalyptic type snow storm and 2) that the main character, Lucas Page, has an uncanny ability to view the world in mathematical vectors and angles. The sci-fi element of seeing the world in this way combined with hunting down an extraordinary sniper appealed to me. While this was a fast read, it ended up only being okay.
I think part of the issue is that these special abilities of Page really come across more like magic than anything else. While they seemed awesome the first time they were used, eventually this talent seemed almost arbitrary in how it was used and how it worked. Also what Page used these skills for became repetitive. I didn't expect this small sci-fi element to be the focus of the book given the thriller nature but I was disappointed by it.
Additionally, I was also annoyed by elements of the plot. While I loved the introduction of the mystery surrounding why law enforcement personnel were being targeted, the resolution was completely lackluster. A random group of Page's grad students help solve the question in under 48 hours. The entire answer of who the mystery sniper is and the motivations behind the crimes were so cliché and ridiculous. I didn't mind, at first, that many of the characters in this were anti-government but the eventual politics involved were just super over-the-top. I didn't like the cult aspects, the Muslim hatred aspects, or the silly red herring aspects. And I especially hated the entire ending.
I did like that Lucas Page was a curmudgeon and snarky. I really enjoyed his antagonistic relationship with the lead FBI agent. I thought the many of the elements of his disabilites were interesting in terms of the practicalities of dealing with them. I also loved his driver, Whittaker, and thought she would have made a better main character. I did not like how Page's relationship with his wife was portrayed. She seemed so pissed at him no real reason other than to add "drama" to the plot. Also I thought the entire subplot involving the sniper and Lucas's family was dumb.
This is apparently the first book of a series starring Lucas Page. As the book was a fast read, I don't mind having read it but I won't be continuing with the series.
So lastly . . .
Thank you St. Martin's Press!
Check out me other reviews at https://thecaptainsquartersblog.wordpress.com/
I picked up this book based on two ideas: 1) that NYC is stuck in an apocalyptic type snow storm and 2) that the main character, Lucas Page, has an uncanny ability to view the world in mathematical vectors and angles. The sci-fi element of seeing the world in this way combined with hunting down an extraordinary sniper appealed to me. While this was a fast read, it ended up only being okay.
I think part of the issue is that these special abilities of Page really come across more like magic than anything else. While they seemed awesome the first time they were used, eventually this talent seemed almost arbitrary in how it was used and how it worked. Also what Page used these skills for became repetitive. I didn't expect this small sci-fi element to be the focus of the book given the thriller nature but I was disappointed by it.
Additionally, I was also annoyed by elements of the plot. While I loved the introduction of the mystery surrounding why law enforcement personnel were being targeted, the resolution was completely lackluster. A random group of Page's grad students help solve the question in under 48 hours. The entire answer of who the mystery sniper is and the motivations behind the crimes were so cliché and ridiculous. I didn't mind, at first, that many of the characters in this were anti-government but the eventual politics involved were just super over-the-top. I didn't like the cult aspects, the Muslim hatred aspects, or the silly red herring aspects. And I especially hated the entire ending.
I did like that Lucas Page was a curmudgeon and snarky. I really enjoyed his antagonistic relationship with the lead FBI agent. I thought the many of the elements of his disabilites were interesting in terms of the practicalities of dealing with them. I also loved his driver, Whittaker, and thought she would have made a better main character. I did not like how Page's relationship with his wife was portrayed. She seemed so pissed at him no real reason other than to add "drama" to the plot. Also I thought the entire subplot involving the sniper and Lucas's family was dumb.
This is apparently the first book of a series starring Lucas Page. As the book was a fast read, I don't mind having read it but I won't be continuing with the series.
So lastly . . .
Thank you St. Martin's Press!
Check out me other reviews at https://thecaptainsquartersblog.wordpress.com/