illustrated_librarian's profile picture

illustrated_librarian 's review for:

One Good Turn by Kate Atkinson
1.0
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

So I tried the first book in the Jackson Brodie series last year and found it pretty mid — some of the character studies were quite good and elements of the mystery interested me, but it failed to come together and felt increasingly messy by the end. As an indication of what a hash it was, it doesn't feel like a spoiler to say that at one point the main character's house explodes and it's not even a big deal. Like at all. 

All this to say, I'm not sure why I picked this up, other than that I thought the series would improve. 

Reader, it did not. 

In this book Jackson's girlfriend is in an Edinburgh Fringe show so he's visiting the city with her. He witnesses a road rage incident, and from there manages to implicate himself in a series of crimes he's got nothing to do with, then attempts to solve them and prove his innocence. 

These books are billed as literary crime, and I take issue with both those adjectives. Let's start with literary: I simply don't think the writing is that good. The character voices are suspiciously samey, possessed of a scolding, up-tight tone that's downright unpleasant to read. Dragging myself through every banal middle-aged man thought Jackson had about every woman he meets to be rewarded with a damp squib of a plot simply wasn't worth it. 

As for crime, the premise of these books could be best described as 'interesting things sometimes happen, oh and Jackson Brodie is also there'. For a detective, supposedly the star of a detective fiction series, this guy does almost no detective work across either book. Most of what's revealed comes to the reader from other character povs, and even then is unsurprising or otherwise convenient to the point I wasn't able to suspend disbelief.

The thing that fully ruined this for me though is that Jackson, who I think Atkinson tries to cast as a flawed but fundamentally good man, fully admits to r*ping his girlfriend in her sleep. As in, he names it as r*pe, ponders how he doesn't know how she'd feel if he were to mention it to her, and then he just... moves on.

Sorry, nope. Thank fuck this was a library loan, eh?

Expand filter menu Content Warnings