Take a photo of a barcode or cover
orcinus_olive 's review for:
The Lost Heir
by Tui T. Sutherland
adventurous
emotional
lighthearted
mysterious
reflective
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
tldr/summary:
The characters in this story are much more flawed than those in the first one, they carry much more baggage with them. And though that may make them more interesting, it also means that a lot of happenings and people in the first half can become obnoxious. This is especially troubling because this story is also much more people-focused and low stakes than the first one. But once the people become more enjoyable/likeable, the world and plot are also quite compelling in most parts.
Long version:
Tsunami is a notably more flawed PoV character than Clay was. She is very self-obsessed, inconsiderate and never thinks her actions through, always assuming things will go perfectly in her favor. This is interesting, but also means she’s fairly insufferable for a good while, until she goes through character development.
In general, the five prophecy dragons are all kind of annoying in the beginning. For some reason, they are much more fond of being mad at each other and making passive-aggressive comments. They made such compelling friends in the first book, but none of that shines through when this adventure starts. But it’s not only their group dynamic that is ruined, the individual dragons are also flat caricatures of themselves. Clay suffers from this especially: He was such a likeable guy in the first story, but here he is reduced to only pointing out how hungry he is every five minutes. Similar things happen with the others too.
Luckily, after Tsunami’s friends are entirely absent for the book’s middle half – a time span that should have probably been shortened a bit – they are allowed to be more complex and enjoyable again; and the friendship between the five also gets a glow-up.
The Sea Kingdom is interesting. Despite it’s surface beauty and peace, it almost immediately has a certain, uncanny aura to it. It’s not even the things that are actually wrong with this place that evoke this feeling – like the threat of an assassin – the culture and people of this place are just so at odds with the vibe the ragtag protagonist group brings everywhere.
The new characters too are quite interesting. Not necessarily likeable, but interesting. Similar to their kingdom, many of the sea dragons aren’t actually evil, but have meaningful flaws that impact the plot and characters. Sometimes, they are just a pain to do deal with because that’s who they are, not because of any villainy. Coral in particular is an interesting case study of a character who is deeply flawed and makes bad decisions with good intentions. Even when she poses an annoying obstacle or does something obviously wrong/bad, it is always more than understandable how she got there. Orca too is a surprisingly complex character, given she doesn’t actually appear in the story.
The plot isn’t too interesting on the surface. The story shines more in how Tsunami figures out herself, what she wants and how to become a better person through exploring her genuinely interesting and creative home culture. Nevertheless there are a few highlights sprinkled into a mostly slow, low-stakes plot line. The discussion of Tsunami’s father is quite gripping, although it would have been better if the characters were allowed to deal with their emotions a bit more. It barely impacted the story, given how big of a deal it should have been.
The assassin’s reveal is well executed. Their true identity and methods are also surprisingly interesting and unexpected. The author made full use of the characters and worldbuilding in very compelling ways. However, the final events of the story after the assassin reveal felt a bit messy and rushed. They should have been given more time, but mostly felt like they are just there to drop everything interesting/necessary on the reader that didn’t get to be mentioned yet. There is a very token effort to make the story end with a bang where there didn’t need to be one. This final action scene clashes with a story that is mostly interpersonal and – though tense – peaceful.