maxarcreads's profile picture

maxarcreads 's review for:

Mad World: Lost Souls by Brandon T. Bernard
3.0

Minor Spoilers
I first want to say this was the author's debut novel and that is a wonderful achievement as writing and publishing a book and putting yourself out there like that is very admirable and as I understand it, he also designed that beautiful cover. Now I want to say this was going to be a 2 for me but what got me to a 3 was the third act and the Cheshire character. I think the main issue is how this book was marketed. This was marketed as a grimsdark, spicy, polygamous, fantasy, alice in wonderland retelling. I am not super familiar with grimsdark but from what I have researched this book meets that definition. But everywhere else it just fell short for me.
For example, the author lists the content warnings as sexual content with a polygamous couple, so I went in expecting it to be spicy. However, I would barely give it a 2 on the spice. there are sexual encounters, but they are brief and most written using broad flowery descriptive words to get around actually describing the act. Books are not required to be spicy there are lots of books that are not and are amazing but when you make it a content warning that there is explicit sex, I expect it to burn.
With it being a fantasy alice in wonderland retelling I expect some kind of magic and wonder and whimsy that I associate with both those features and I think they can be achieved within the grimsdark genre. But the only magic and whimsey was alice ending up in this new realm, people not aging, people of this realm having amazing hair colors (nothing traditional like in our realm) like pink and purple and have matching eye colors and later in act three finding out that wonderland is able to have sway or magic over its lands. I just feel like there could have been more. That is also my feelings when it comes to the 3 of the 4 main characters is that they could have just been more. You have March a powerful sword woman with a way of standing out by her hair and manner of dress but yet I forgot about her half the time as there was nothing remarkable about her or what she did in the book and any interactions or scenes with her were brief. Then there is Johnathan who is inspired by the mad hatter who in my opinion was just felt like there was not depth and was bland and when you have the mad hatter as inspiration, I feel like you could just do more. I just felt like both of these two were one noted with Johnathan being a little more simply because he had more involvement in the story line. Then the Mary Ann who is the Alice in this story was dull and at times unlikable especially we find out she is having an affair with a married man which is why she ran off that night as she was discovered by her mother and that's what started her journey into wonderland and that she is so thrown off by her situation with being in this new realm and what she sees going on "unaliving" that I feel like she spends most of it in a state of shock or just existing within the storyline.
Now Cheshire on the other hand was a complex character who I feel perfectly embodies what this book was trying to achieve with a grimsdark, fantasy, Alice in wonderland who saved the book for me, and I just wish all the characters were like him, but they didn't seem to come alive until the 3rd act.

Now all reading is subjective and maybe I am not the target audience for this book, but with this being a series and ending how it does with everything picking up and starting to get interesting I would think the storyline in the next book would start off there and be able to carry that momentum and be a really interesting read. However, for me for this book I can only give it a 3.