This felt like a waste of characters after the first book. Olivia’s arc felt ruined. Any growth she had in the first book was gone. Ruby was better, she felt a lot more tolerable than she did in the first. Helen’s story was just ok. It felt rushed. Actually, every story except Amy Rose and John’s story felt rushed. Amy Rose and John did have a lot of growth which was nice to see. I did like that she managed for herself and built her dreams I liked that John was there to without pressuring her. Overall though, four love stories could’ve and probably should’ve been separate books