It's just... not for me. I saw someone say that it almost ruins the magic and mystery of lord of the rings, and I'm glad I never read enough to get to that point, I totally understand their statement. There's too much going on and the characters aren't interesting to me. Still love Tolkien though!! I just think this wasn't anywhere near publishing level and perhaps he didn't want it published at all. I doubt I'll read all the other posthumous books they've released in his name.