illustrated_librarian's profile picture

illustrated_librarian 's review for:

Devotion by Madeline Stevens
1.0
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

Ella Crawford is lonely, so broke she sometimes seduces strange men in the hopes they'll buy her dinner, and generally adrift in New York City. After blagging her way into a nannying job for Upper East Side couple James and Lonnie, she's swept into their world of old money, extravagant soirรฉes and effortless beauty. Ella finds herself becoming obsessed with Lonnie's seemingly perfect life in an increasingly deranged way. 

Why is Ella obsessed with Lonnie, you ask? Unclear! She's rich, skinny, and white, and that's enough I guess? As became a theme with this book, the obsessive nature of Ella and Lonnie's relationship felt very underdeveloped. Ostensibly rooted in Ella's simultaneous attraction to Lonnie's perfect life and her resentment of her privilege, this basis for the obsession is only vaguely referred to a couple of times. 

What could have been an exploration of the complex class tensions and power dynamics that accompany working in your employer's home was instead just a vehicle for strained attempts to create a suburban noir feel that floundered due to lack of tension. Everything felt very 2D and purposeless, including Ella's weird, forced ~feral girl behaviour that was honestly eyeroll-inducing.

The prose tended veer into fussy territory, with some faux deep navel-gazing that is pulled off by very, very few. There are also some extremely troubling drug-induced bedroom scenes towards the end of the book that felt clumsily handled and completely unnecessary. Though to be fair, I was never sure why any of the cardboard cutout characters ever did anything, so maybe those scenes were just a variation on that theme. 

This had none of the complex interplay of privilege and power in relationships of something like Conversations With Friends, it lacked the smart social commentary of Such a Fun Age, and if you want to read about a chaotic, broke millenial woman interacting with someone else's wife you're far better off with Luster. The fact I finished this should be taken as a reflection on my sheer stubbornness, rather than a recommendation that you do the same. Avoid, avoid, avoid ๐Ÿ™…๐Ÿผโ€โ™€๏ธ๐Ÿ™…๐Ÿผโ€โ™€๏ธ