Take a photo of a barcode or cover
birdykinsreads 's review for:
The Writing Retreat
by Julia Bartz
I actually really liked reading this book up until things went totally off the rails, and even then I swept through it quickly to see how it would possibly end.
But, let’s be fucking real here, the novel our main character Alex is writing is nowhere near worth killing for. I don’t think I’d even bother skinning my knee for this shite. As someone who LOVED The Plot by Jean Hanff Korelitz I am mortally offended on her behalf for the comparisons, the book within a book in THAT book was actually good. The fact that the this whole story hinges on the idea these excerpts are proof she’s writing a masterpiece worth stealing just kind of undercuts the whole thing and then the last half feels a bit like a tv show trying to drag out the thrills with misdirection and will they or won’t they escape attempts until the season finale finally comes.
That being said, I liked Alex. I liked her weird falling out with ex-best friend Wren (also at the retreat because what are the odds). I liked their fever dream spicy scenes and the psychological thrills before the writing retreat turns into a free for all insanity massacre. I feel like it was making sense until it really really wasn’t. The twists were a bit too much slippery noodle spirals. Ya know?
Also, writing the one black character having to deal with racist micro aggressions for no real storytelling rhyme or reason felt pretty gross to me. The pointed gleeful slave moment? Fucking weird. Why do white authors have to make their villains do some questionable problematic shit to show they’re the villain? We been knew.
Anyway, all said and done I’m not sure it’s worth recommending. I’m really glad I got it from the library and didn’t end up buying it after all.
But, let’s be fucking real here, the novel our main character Alex is writing is nowhere near worth killing for. I don’t think I’d even bother skinning my knee for this shite. As someone who LOVED The Plot by Jean Hanff Korelitz I am mortally offended on her behalf for the comparisons, the book within a book in THAT book was actually good. The fact that the this whole story hinges on the idea these excerpts are proof she’s writing a masterpiece worth stealing just kind of undercuts the whole thing and then the last half feels a bit like a tv show trying to drag out the thrills with misdirection and will they or won’t they escape attempts until the season finale finally comes.
That being said, I liked Alex. I liked her weird falling out with ex-best friend Wren (also at the retreat because what are the odds). I liked their fever dream spicy scenes and the psychological thrills before the writing retreat turns into a free for all insanity massacre. I feel like it was making sense until it really really wasn’t. The twists were a bit too much slippery noodle spirals. Ya know?
Also, writing the one black character having to deal with racist micro aggressions for no real storytelling rhyme or reason felt pretty gross to me. The pointed gleeful slave moment? Fucking weird. Why do white authors have to make their villains do some questionable problematic shit to show they’re the villain? We been knew.
Anyway, all said and done I’m not sure it’s worth recommending. I’m really glad I got it from the library and didn’t end up buying it after all.