chrisssl 's review for:

Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke
3.5
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

At no point in the novel did this reader fail to marvel at the brilliance and craftsmanship of the author.  That this is a debut novel coming in at a bewildering thousand-page-plus page-count, is remarkable.  Its length is intimidating (and not altogether justified) but its scope and ambition is commendable.  And yet, while I'm full of praise for the author's abilities, the novel itself is not without some key weaknesses which have undoubtedly led many readers to give up this door-stopper of a book well before its qualities can be best appreciated.

The titular characters of Jonathan Strange and Gilbert Norrell are written vividly and exhaustively, with enough depth to help carry such a long book.  Their interplay is quite fun and imaginative and insightful.  The only problem is one must read an entire first third of the novel in order to reach this part of the book where Jonathan Strange fully enters the picture.  Several times I had to force myself to continue reading during the first volume of the novel.  The book's Dickensian-style, fascinating English-regency setting and a wonderfully understated and uniquely academic approach to magic could not save this reader from the boredom of watching Mr. Norrell (sans Strange) dryly work his way into his reputation.

The novel wears its Dickens and Austen inspirations proudly on its sleeve, to the point where any fantasy-genre inspirations seem loose and indistinct (which should be an achievement in and of itself).  In accordance with that, the novel delights in long digressions with short-stories of side characters which populate the world in little asides, and then are rarely seen again.  While it does add some colour to this world, it also adds a great deal of length and heft to a novel struggling under its own page-count.  The final two volumes of the novel are more compelling as they have the dynamism of the two English magicians and various episodes in the Napoleonic wars to propel itself to a satisfying conclusion.  But issues of pacing surrounding the first act remain and one wonders if it could not have been significantly condensed without losing the characterization of Mr. Norrell.