I really wound up adoring this read. It was such adorable holiday read and it just made me smile. Baily reminded me so much of me as a person. It also had some many fun "holiday" element. This book also did one of my most hated elements in book in such a unique way. I also really enjoyed the feature of animals and puppies in this book. I loved the bookstore as a primary setting. It was a great and prefect holiday read. Will def read more by this author in the future.