kaylaramoutar's profile picture

kaylaramoutar 's review for:

A Deadly Education by Naomi Novik
4.0

Simply writing this review because I’ve seen a lot of reviews that complain heartily about ADE and I’d like to counter them as a member of the “”diverse”” community. To start: 1) this is my first Novik book so I’m not a stan defending her to her “haters”. 2) I’m not sure what race the reviewer is that hated this book, so when I refer to white people I refer to them in general not specifically that reviewer as a person. If the reviewers are white (and some others are, but I won’t be linking them) then I hope they read my review, and other BIPOC’s, and see if their review is out of place.

I’m sure you can find the main review I’m discussing in my review. I found their review honestly deliberately berating and intentionally off-putting. I don’t know what Novik did to scorn them so badly, but the review felt personal. Some of their points had merit, but a lot of their points were backed up with examples that weren’t true. They complained about Yi Liu and how they didn’t know which was her last name and “El never called anyone else by her last name” — she calls Orion “Lake” half the time and also referred to Chloe by her last name to her face multiple times. A comment on the review said that both Yi and Liu could be used as first and last names, and that it wasn’t a problem in the book. If someone in the community isn’t bothered by it, and overall it isn’t harmful, I don’t think it’s something to write the book off on.

The argument over El not calling her grandparents by their proper Hindu term is f*cking stupid. I can say this because my grandpa is Hindu ☺️ 1) she met them once as a young child and barely remembers it 2) they try to KILL HER, why would she refer to them with proper grandparent names?? I wouldn’t. 3) she grew up in Britain with her white mother. It would have been completely jarring narratively if she she was calling them by Hindu names, and reviewers would have complained it was inconsistent or stereotyping. Just because she speaks Marathi doesn’t mean she should be part of the “inner community” and that’s ok. Not everyone who speaks a different language needs to assimilate to that culture fully. The reviewer also wrote “El has no personal connection to Indian culture” — I don’t have the time or energy to explain how biracial people feel separated from either one or both of their cultures. Speaking of, “making El biracial seems like an afterthought” is incredibly rude and teetering on racism. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with making her biracial, whether it’s an afterthought or not. It’s explained why El has no connection to her Indian heritage and how she barely has any to her white mother’s family as well.

As I said I don’t know the reviewer’s race, but I feel pretty comfortable in saying they’re not biracial. It’s completely normal to not feel fully in one race, and El doesn’t. I don’t. She discusses that she wishes she could belong to one of the Indianian enclaves but doesn’t feel like she could because of what happened when she was a kid, and she doesn’t fit in with the white British people she lives with in the commune. The reviewer complained about the term “weak tea” to describe her skin but that’s literally what white people say about brown people! They use food to describe our skin tone. Whether or not that’s an issue from Novik’s writing or unconscious bias, it’s accurate.

Sometimes I feel like white people get more up in arms about lack of- or too much diversity in books or movies than “diverse” people. Diversity is a white word as it is. See here: “Diversity, as Tania Canas so succinctly puts it in her essay “Diversity is a White Word,” is about making sense of difference “through the white lens ... by creating, curating and demanding palatable definitions of ‘diversity’ but only in relation to what this means in terms of whiteness”. It’s the literary equivalent of “ethnic” restaurants: they please white people because they provide them with “exotic” new flavours, but if they don’t appease white people’s sensitive taste buds they’re not worth a damn.” (Alicia Elliott, A MIND SPREAD OUT ON THE GROUND).

I saw a different reviewer saying that the inclusion of different cultures was heavy handed, like it was too much. Not believable that there would be so much diversity in a school like this. That is, without a doubt, a racist thought. A lot of white people grow up in circles with mostly white people, maybe a smattering of colour here or there. Their circles and worlds aren’t as “diverse” as the school is and that makes it unbelievable to them, makes Novik’s inclusion “heavy handed”. The “diversity” they seek must not be too much or its unbelievable and thus participating in stereotypes etc. Some white people just can’t believe that there are non-white people out there who act like non-white people, whatever that means. If someone in a novel has an ethnic name and speaks a different language, it’s “too much”. “Trying too hard.” I don’t know how to tell you that all ethnic characters don’t, and shouldn’t, speak full proper English.

Novik did fuck up hard with the locs paragraph, but I’m glad she already released a statement about it. She said she’ll be deleting the paragraph entirely and rewriting the hair section, and I think that’s great. Overall I think she did a decent job with the inclusion of other cultures that I believe that the rest of the series will be racially more sound in the places she lacked.

If you made it this far, cool. Thanks for reading. I hope if you haven’t read this book you give it a chance, because it’s fun and interesting! The world building is good, in-depth, and completely different than other books/worlds. Give it a chance and form your own opinions