Take a photo of a barcode or cover
hongjoongie 's review for:
Biography of X
by Catherine Lacey
challenging
dark
mysterious
reflective
sad
tense
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
But l know now that a person always exceeds and resists the limits of a story about them, and no matter how widely we set the boundaries, their subjectivity spills over, drips at the edges, then rushes out completely. People are, it seems, too complicated to sit still inside a narrative, but that hasn't stopped anyone from trying, desperately trying, to compact a life into pages.
"The happiest years are the shortest. We only notice them after they're gone … Therefore, the attempt to avoid suffering is the most suicidal impulse of all. It is to ask your life to go by so quickly that you never see a moment of it."
A loss tinged with shame, regret, or a sense of something unfinished is the most dangerous sort, a black-hole grief that pulls a person relentlessly toward its center, and when our lives come to one of these we are forced to either bow before it or detach completely.
An ambitious, wildly imaginative book. I love the set up and world building, and I loved the exploration of grief, if we can really know someone (or ourselves), and how our past shapes our identity(ies). But ultimately I think this book is a bit too ambitious. For me, the dystopian alternative history mixed with all of X’s performance art pieces became a bit overwhelming, especially the latter. The beginning and ending were great, but the middle, where Lucca is interviewing the people X was involved with, felt repetitive. I also never felt an emotional connection with either Lucca or X; for X, I wish there was a more clear connection between what she experienced as a child with how she constructed her art and how she treated others as an adult. But we’re only privy to what Lucca, the narrator, lets us know, and maybe that’s the point, but it dampened my reading experience a bit. Still really good, but sad it wasn’t a 5. Read if you enjoyed The People in the Trees, Trust, and Trust Exercise.