illustrated_librarian's profile picture

illustrated_librarian 's review for:

Lost in the Garden by Adam S. Leslie
4.5
adventurous dark funny mysterious reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

In a dystopia-adjacent England, a funhouse mirror version of our own, everyone is raised knowing you don't go to Almanby. Look both ways before you cross the street, don't talk to strangers. Don't go to Almanby.

Except that's exactly where Rachel, Antonia, and Heather are headed. Rachel needs to deliver a mysterious package, Heather needs to find her boyfriend Steven, and Antonia has a devastating crush on Heather. And so they set off on a road trip through the idyllic and perilous English countryside, dodging the dead who have risen - sort of - and haunted by eerie voices fizzing over shortwave radio and the jingling of ice cream vans. 

In this novel, reality itself is ailing. Geography shifts around, summer lasts forever, and time is slippery. This uncanny backdrop is soaked in the nostalgia of English childhood summers and the unique weirdness of rural village life. A cloying sense of disquiet builds as the characters meander towards Almanby with the continual sense that there's something just out of sight or beyond their grasp, everything familiar yet slightly.... off.

Leslie manages to translate this incredibly psychedelic experience into straightforward prose coupled with punchy dialogue and fun characters. I was surprised by how markedly different this way of writing the weird felt; it foregoes formal experimentation in favour of being a genuine page-turner with characters that pop, and still achieves an intensely trippy, glitchy atmosphere throughout. In a way this reminded me of Vandermeer's Area X, but a very English folk-horror take, in that there's something going on beyond human understanding. We see the external effects, but will we ever really know what's up with Almanby?

The reading experience feels like a hazy, half-remembered dream. Like having the sun in your eyes, getting heatstroke, being overtired, and high on sugar all at once. For the avoidance of all doubt, I mean this as a good thing. 

So read this book! Don't go to Almanby!

And if you want an ice cream? Tough.