That book is a good books that contains some short storys that are great are others that are good but not more. Thta why i only give it four stars, some of them really deserve a five stars, but other deserve more like a three point five or a four stars. But anyway for my first read of this author, i find it very interesting for the amateur of scifi and some of the story are of must read for them like minority report and the one that serve to make the total recall movie, both two good movie by the way. So maybe not the best short story book, but still a good one that deserve to be read!