Take a photo of a barcode or cover
jotundottir 's review for:
Tell Me What You Did
by Carter Wilson
I'm quite disappointed with this book. Someone recommended it to me and the plot seemed so interesting, but sadly I can't say I enjoyed it much.
There are two thing (besides the cat) that I liked about this book, the one I liked the most was the pacing. I think the author makes a good job at it, every time I felt things were starting to feel a bit repetitive or tension was too down, something happened that made me sort of curious and want to continue. Another thing related to pacing that I liked was that I felt things connected really well between chapters. The second thing I liked was how the author kept me guessing who Spoilerwas kidnapped (this is not the main question of the book of who this guy is, but about something smaller that you know very close to the start so not a big spoiler if you want to check). Although my first guess was correct, things later made me think maybe I was wrong.
Now, the bad. I knew the answer to the big question of "who is this guy" around 40%, I feel the answer was too typical and common if you are someone that read or watches a lot of crime books/shows and things like that. But I could have dealt with that if Poe wasn't so insufferable. She's boring and unlikable. At first I was trying to give her a chance, because you don't always need to like the main character, but at least they have to be interesting. Poe is not only a mess of a character, but things always go her way (or at least in a sort of/mostly positive way) just because she's the main character. Not because she's smart, not because she is cautious and plans things carefully. It's plain luck due to being the main character. I'll add more details but they have spoilers. The cat is definitely the best character just because he hissed at Poe. I also didn't really believe the way she talks on the stream, she tells things like a narrator would, not like someone under a lot of stress. She adds a lot of details that aren't necessary at all.
SpoilerThe fact Poe actually killed the right guy is hard to believe. Sure, the dating profile is a good idea, but that guy could actually have been a random weirdo, she didn't really check that much, she had one date and that was it. She didn't even try the trick of saying the safe word to test if he was the right guy or not, he already knew she was the daughter. She doesn't seem to have much of a strategy about how to uncover if that's the right guy and deal with him, which wouldn't be a problem if she didn't act like she was a badass and so prepared.
SpoilerShe's also incredibly selfish with the way she treat her dad almost forcing him to hear how she killed someone when he clearly said no to hearing the details. The sentence she says of "you don't decided which truths you hear" is one of the reasons I dislike her more. It's plain evil. And again, I like evil characters but they have to be smart and interesting. But she's not smart, nor interesting (by the end of the book we barely know anything about her besides killing and podcasting). I think the book might have been more interesting with the twist that she killed the wrong guy, Hindley is actually her mum's killer and she has to deal with the fact she took an innocent life.
There are two thing (besides the cat) that I liked about this book, the one I liked the most was the pacing. I think the author makes a good job at it, every time I felt things were starting to feel a bit repetitive or tension was too down, something happened that made me sort of curious and want to continue. Another thing related to pacing that I liked was that I felt things connected really well between chapters. The second thing I liked was how the author kept me guessing who Spoilerwas kidnapped (this is not the main question of the book of who this guy is, but about something smaller that you know very close to the start so not a big spoiler if you want to check). Although my first guess was correct, things later made me think maybe I was wrong.
Now, the bad. I knew the answer to the big question of "who is this guy" around 40%, I feel the answer was too typical and common if you are someone that read or watches a lot of crime books/shows and things like that. But I could have dealt with that if Poe wasn't so insufferable. She's boring and unlikable. At first I was trying to give her a chance, because you don't always need to like the main character, but at least they have to be interesting. Poe is not only a mess of a character, but things always go her way (or at least in a sort of/mostly positive way) just because she's the main character. Not because she's smart, not because she is cautious and plans things carefully. It's plain luck due to being the main character. I'll add more details but they have spoilers. The cat is definitely the best character just because he hissed at Poe. I also didn't really believe the way she talks on the stream, she tells things like a narrator would, not like someone under a lot of stress. She adds a lot of details that aren't necessary at all.
SpoilerThe fact Poe actually killed the right guy is hard to believe. Sure, the dating profile is a good idea, but that guy could actually have been a random weirdo, she didn't really check that much, she had one date and that was it. She didn't even try the trick of saying the safe word to test if he was the right guy or not, he already knew she was the daughter. She doesn't seem to have much of a strategy about how to uncover if that's the right guy and deal with him, which wouldn't be a problem if she didn't act like she was a badass and so prepared.
SpoilerShe's also incredibly selfish with the way she treat her dad almost forcing him to hear how she killed someone when he clearly said no to hearing the details. The sentence she says of "you don't decided which truths you hear" is one of the reasons I dislike her more. It's plain evil. And again, I like evil characters but they have to be smart and interesting. But she's not smart, nor interesting (by the end of the book we barely know anything about her besides killing and podcasting). I think the book might have been more interesting with the twist that she killed the wrong guy, Hindley is actually her mum's killer and she has to deal with the fact she took an innocent life.