3.5 probably. I've read a bit of modern historical romance and this is a very good debut that I had just a few issues with. As far as storytelling goes, I found the will-they-won't-they and what-about-now to be a little too repetitive and tedious, although others might find it heightens the tension and makes for a compelling read. Also, although I liked the duke overall, I didn't like the looming, physical intimidation that was written into so many of his scenes. Otherwise, this is a pretty good example of good, modern historical romance and really promising start to a series! I enjoyed the late-Victorian setting, the bluestockings at Oxford angle, the glimpses into British Parliament, the women's movement and developing friendships, the prominent role of consent, and our survivalist lead character.

Content notes: steamy sex scenes, discussion of contractual sexual relationship, Victorian era sexism, sexual assault (interrupted), estrangement from family,