ok so I totally get why some people wouldn't love this because it is a massively complicated web of relationships between the main four characters and the fact that Joy is in love with Malcolm but falling for Fox makes it admittedly less of a by-the-books romance. none of this changes the fact that I loved it so much and all of the characters were really interesting to me and I just think there's so much going on in Malcolm and Joy's relationship specifically that I found fascinating so... five stars anyway