birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

The Bandit Queens by Parini Shroff
3.0
dark funny slow-paced

… 𝓫𝓸𝓸𝓴𝓬𝓵𝓾𝓫 𝓻𝓮𝓬𝓪𝓹

I’m so behind I feel like I went to bookclub for this one seven million years ago! But better late than never!

My second bookclub read The Bandit Queens by Parini Shroff, and for the first time in all bookclub history (anywhere) we all rated this book exactly the same! 3 ⭐️s all around!

The Bandit Queens is about women in a rural Indian village, trying to make more for themselves through a microloan program but at the mercy of the oppressive patriarchal state and the local men in their lives. Geeta’s husband disappeared years ago and she’s been treated as the town pariah ever since, rumours swirling of how she may have killed him. So, when another woman in their microloan group needs disposing of a husband she comes to Geeta, after all she’s the expert right? 

This book was sort of mismarketed, I think. I went in expecting a vigilante female type of story, I’m visualizing something like The Pink Saris—murdering trash men and taking their power back but that’s not at all what was delivered. While there’s some interesting and important discussion in this book about the microloan system, women’s rights in the most rural places, and marriage as control more than anything—there just wasn’t enough agency in these women to deliver on the back cover promises.

I felt like this book did a lot of things I liked but just not well enough. In particular it was very funny, I enjoyed the writing style and the central friendship but none of us at Bookclub believed the actions that propel the story made much sense. Often it felt like plot lines would be abandoned or characters would act unpredictably and illogically almost to a ridiculous degree, undoing a lot of character development that came before. It did feel repetitive and like the author wanted to shoehorn in references & ideas even at the expensive of the book. This was a super slow read for me and if it weren’t for Bookclub I may have accidentally DNFed it.

I think how funny it was saved it as a whole for me, and the female friendships. I wish that was in deeper and better focus.

I’m neutral about this one—wouldn’t really recommend it but I think I’d read what Shroff writes next.