I genuinely don't know why a lot of people dislike this one so much. It was, by far, my favorite book in the Trilogy. Sure, the climax was a tad rushed and my heart broke for A LOT of characters (Spoiler I will never truly get over Harshaw) but I thought it was very well written. The book didn't go where you would expect it to go, and I thoroughly enjoyed that. I'm glad it didn't leave me a sobbing mess of feeling crying over the death of my favorite character. Close shave, that one.