this book has me excited for what more Sarah Schmidt will bring in the future. I feel like, with 4 different narrators, the story should have been longer. if kept the same length, we could have gone with 2 or 3 narrators. at times the narrative did have me scratching my head and I would need to re-read a paragraph or two to re-calibrate. but i definitely enjoyed the story, the setting, and the ending! a solid, strong 4 out of 5 from me!