I thought it was a well crafted story of Sirens in the sea against a real life backdrop. 

I liked the dual timeline and how it featured those exiled back in the 19th century to Australia and how awful scenario - I’ve read a book about that in detail before and it’s both a horrific and captivating time in the UK and Australia’s history. 

While the book was easy to figure out and fairly predictable in most aspects, I found the unfolding of the mystery well written and interesting. It held my attention and I enjoyed the characters of Lucy, Jess, Mary, and Eliza. I liked that they looked out for each other and were loyal even when they didn’t have to be. I love a book where women champion and stand by other women. 

Thanks to Netgalley for the advanced copy of this book.