Take a photo of a barcode or cover
kfren 's review for:
If He Had Been with Me
by Laura Nowlin
A very very quick read
I was shocked at how fast but also slow the story progressed. I wish for me. I hate and love the way it ends all the same
Amending my review a few hours later as i’ve had more time to process it and sit with it
I’ve decided to decrease it by one star
After sitting with it for awhile I’m honestly kind of disappointed in the ending.
Not because it wasn’t a happy one — I don’t need a happy ending.
It’s that it felt rushed. Cramped. Like all this slow, intimate build-up just got shoved aside at the last second. The whole book is spent getting to know Autumn, sitting with her in her pain and awkwardness and longing, and then I feel like the story just bailed out before it really finished what it started.
It’s not a bad book. But the way it ended kind of broke the trust I built with it. It didn’t do Autumn justice. And it didn’t really do the reader justice either.
I was shocked at how fast but also slow the story progressed. I wish for me. I hate and love the way it ends all the same
Amending my review a few hours later as i’ve had more time to process it and sit with it
I’ve decided to decrease it by one star
After sitting with it for awhile I’m honestly kind of disappointed in the ending.
Not because it wasn’t a happy one — I don’t need a happy ending.
It’s that it felt rushed. Cramped. Like all this slow, intimate build-up just got shoved aside at the last second. The whole book is spent getting to know Autumn, sitting with her in her pain and awkwardness and longing, and then I feel like the story just bailed out before it really finished what it started.
It’s not a bad book. But the way it ended kind of broke the trust I built with it. It didn’t do Autumn justice. And it didn’t really do the reader justice either.