mathildur's profile picture

mathildur 's review for:

The Ghosts of Sherwood by Carrie Vaughn
2.5

I have to preface this review with saying how little I apparently remember of the story of Robin Hood. I fear my reading experience with The Ghosts of Sherwood is colored by the fact that I didn’t know who many of the main characters even were, such as the infamous ghost of Sherwood after whom the novella gets its name. I also haven’t actually read any stories about Robin Hood, all my knowledge comes from the animated movie. This means that my rating is most likely much lower than it would have been if this novella had allowed me to return to a well-known and well-loved story.

The novella is quite short, which means that it’s a fast read. This works partly in its favor, because the story doesn’t drag and it kept me interested throughout. But it also works disfavorably, because I wanted so much more than it was able to give. I only barely got to know these wonderful and brave children of Robin Hood before the story was over. I also think it was a little too messy to shift povs in such a short story, rather than focusing on just one character. That being said, I did find the story and the characters engaging and I would have loved to read more about them! I definitely think this novella could be a hit for a younger audience who is familiar with Robin Hood’s story. Sadly, that audience was not me.