More than 4 stars - I somehow liked this more than the first book, which I didn’t think was possible. I loved being back in the world of Graves Glen with the Jones witches and Penhallows. I thought that the grumpy and sunshine trope mixed with a little bit of manic pixie dream girl was really fun. The premise was interesting, possibly more-so than in the first book, and the chemistry was so good. This was so swoony, but also had me laughing a lot. Definitely a super fun read!