jukietoss's profile picture

jukietoss 's review for:

Disappoint Me by Nicola Dinan
5.0
emotional hopeful reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Yes
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

What an absolutely stunning tale of love, forgiveness, family, and living. It is so tender, so gentle and generous and big-hearted. It's the story of a 30-year old trans woman, Max, living her life where we the reader gain access to it at a particular moment in time that is both significant and grounded in the context of all her previous moments. It's also the story of Vincent, his present and his past, and how two people who meet and connect at a moment in time figure out how to care for each other and merge stories. That's not a ground-breaking premise; plenty of authors try to tell stories where characters existed before we met them and they get to know each other on the page. But the way Dinan did it is fundamentally exceptional. It is so deeply human and rich in its realness. 

She told Max's story so effectively and with such tenderness, I feel privileged to have heard it. I'm grateful for how thoroughly Dinan let us in to Max's relationships with her family, her friends, and Vincent. I also love to read a story where a big friendship is central and core and not made less than when a romantic relationship enters the scene. I loved Simone, and I loved how Simone and Max cared for each other, even when it was hard. 

Dinan allows her characters to be flawed, to err without repair, to make things harder for themselves. But in no way did this make the characters frustrating (as may have happened in a lesser book). Here, the humanity is a strength, their love despite their mistakes and their flaws is so rich and so believable. We are all more than one thing. 

I recommend this book for anyone looking for a deeply human story where connection is both central and imperfect, where the characters are worth rooting for, and their goodness is unmistakable even if not pristine. It's ultimately affirming, uplifting, and hopeful.