kaylaramoutar's profile picture

kaylaramoutar 's review for:

The First Evil by R.L. Stine
5.0

I first read this book series when I was 12 and LOVED THEM. There’s a scene that has genuinely lived in my head rent free for the last 16 years. It’s a scene that happens in the school showers and I literally LITERALLY think about it every time I shower. Can you imagine how many times I’ve thought of the scene in 16 years?! The scene was in this first book and I was so, so thrilled to read that it was as terrifying as I remember it.

Of course, the book isn’t the pinnacle of literature. It’s 150~ pages of paranormal horror written for middle grade... but damn I enjoyed it. I was kind of surprised how young it sounded when I started it; the girls are very dramatic, there’s a lot of shrieking when speaking, drama ensues over a boy who is as boring as a doornail, there’s a lot of adverbs etc. But once I was into it it was easy to ignore that it was definitely written for middle schoolers and just enjoy the story.

I’d say it’s probably a 4 in relation to story/plot, 2/3 in relation to the writing (it’s pretty juvenile sounding even for middle grade, if you compare it to more modern MG like Schwab’s newer series or even older series like The Golden Compass which is written like it’s for adults tbh but that’s not the point here). But it’s a 5 in relation to my emotions!! And it’s my review and I can rate it what I want