You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

kaylaramoutar's profile picture

kaylaramoutar 's review for:

The Gracekeepers by Kirsty Logan
3.0



The Gracekeepers was very whimsical and beautifully written, but overall disappointing. The idea of the story and the Scottish myths/fairytales was a fantastic base for a story. Unfortunately, the lack of direct plot, which is sometimes a good thing, was a hindrance here. There were minor plots like Jarrow's insistence that North and Ainsel take the house - will they, won't they, etc - and Avalon's anger about it, but it wasn't strong enough to carry the novel. Callanish's minor plot was getting to her mother, and while that had some substance to it, it mostly just involved us having to deal with Flitch or whatever his name was... And he was horrible.

I think the novel didn't benefit from having so many different POVs. I don't think any of them - outside of North and Callanish - were important. Once they met and we had that spark, and the insistence in their sections where they couldn't stop thinking of each other, I was waiting for some sort of ... more? between them. The 'After' chapter - consisting of three pages - was not enough to fulfill that need. I also found the ending quite rushed and somewhat lacking in the magical writing I had become accustomed to. It was written much differently than the rest of the novel.

I know this review sounds like I didn't enjoy the novel - I did. I thought it was interesting and wanted to see what happened to our two heroines, but ultimately found it lacked the gumption I needed it to. I'll definitely be checking out Logan's other works though, because as I said the writing was beautiful and the basic idea of the novel was quite interesting.