Take a photo of a barcode or cover
goodeyreads 's review for:
A Song Among the Silence
by Julie Janis
Thank you to the author for an eARC.
A GOOD DEBUT.
BLOG || INSTAGRAM
An enjoyable read! I liked this for an author debut. It was well written and had a good cast.
I liked the main characters and thought they had solid depth and intentions. Kota and Derrick were easy to follow and cheer for. The magic system could have used some more boundary explanation but it was unique. The concept was there and I understood most of the parameters.
There were quite a few plot holes I noticed. A mix of wondering why someone had made that choice or needing more on a side character to further explain the situation. Even though the story moves well with action and slower moments there’s room for the pieces that were missing.
It was unfortunate that most of the antagonists were POC. The evil stepmother and stepsister vibes were alive and well. As were many, many other tropes. It took away from the surprising twists because you could see them from a mile away.
Derrick and Kota have a sweet burgeoning relationship. Personally, I’d love some angst, but it’s tender and I like it well enough. Killian is a great morally grey character. I’m curious how he further fits into the series.
A mixed bag, but a positive debut. I look forward to the next book in the series.
Overall audience notes:
- YA Fantasy
- Language: none
- Romance: flirting
- Violence: physical and magical altercations, torture, near death experiences
A GOOD DEBUT.
BLOG || INSTAGRAM
An enjoyable read! I liked this for an author debut. It was well written and had a good cast.
I liked the main characters and thought they had solid depth and intentions. Kota and Derrick were easy to follow and cheer for. The magic system could have used some more boundary explanation but it was unique. The concept was there and I understood most of the parameters.
There were quite a few plot holes I noticed. A mix of wondering why someone had made that choice or needing more on a side character to further explain the situation. Even though the story moves well with action and slower moments there’s room for the pieces that were missing.
It was unfortunate that most of the antagonists were POC. The evil stepmother and stepsister vibes were alive and well. As were many, many other tropes. It took away from the surprising twists because you could see them from a mile away.
Derrick and Kota have a sweet burgeoning relationship. Personally, I’d love some angst, but it’s tender and I like it well enough. Killian is a great morally grey character. I’m curious how he further fits into the series.
A mixed bag, but a positive debut. I look forward to the next book in the series.
Overall audience notes:
- YA Fantasy
- Language: none
- Romance: flirting
- Violence: physical and magical altercations, torture, near death experiences