This book is a compilation of three separate short stories that are all interlaced with one another, and with John Green's name on the cover, I honestly wasn't sure what to expect. I hadn't read anything by the other two authors, but John is hit and miss, for me.

The first story was my favorite. The narrator was lovable and the plot was cute. The second story (John's) was a little meh, but the romance was cute enough to enjoy. The third story, I barely finished. The narrator was horrible and obnoxious, there is some ridiculous misinformation about pet pigs, and the ending was disappointing and involved serious butchering of the characters from the first two. If I based the rating just on the third story, this would be 1/5 stars instead of 2/5.