i really thought i would love this. the concept seemed right up my alley. the beginning was promising. i didn’t understand the characters’ motivations (esp in regards to tally. there was no reason WHY scottie liked her so much, she had quite literally zero redeeming qualities. even manipulators are supposed to be charismatic?!?!?), parts were too cringey (even though it was supposed to be “camp”), the characters didnt have enough chemistry, scottie should have apologized more for being so rude in the beginning, the conflict didnt feel like it got all the way resolved, and the rom com references did not feel genuine. a few of the sports-y parts were nice. some of the side characters were cool