proseamongstthorns's profile picture

proseamongstthorns 's review for:

Caraval by Stephanie Garber
4.0

In Caraval, we explore a mysterious and magical performance that doubles as an exciting competition; with this year’s prize being a wish. There’s love, betrayal, heartache and, of course, magic seeping from every pore. I honestly can’t believe it’s taken me this long to experience the wonder that is Caraval!

The world truly comes to life around you. Following a sceptic in our main character Scarlett makes the magic feel more vibrant as she doubts and questions everything. I’m desperate to return to this world Garber has created in the next book.

For me, the characters were a mixed bag. I found Legend’s characterisation frustratingly mixed and confusing - one second he’s brilliant and kind, the next a villain. Scarlett and Donatella were also a little annoying in this, they felt a little like caricatures who were little more than their main few traits. I hope that they’ll continue to grow in the series and develop.

I really enjoyed reading this book though! As I said, the world building is fantastic, the plot (and twists) exciting and the love interests brilliant. I hope this continues in the next two books!