First off this cover is everything. Everything! It was fun revisiting the original tales in graphic novel form and seeing them from that perspective. The illustrations were great and it really just makes me want to watch the movie ASAP.

The 4 new tales, however, were just okay to me. The coloring and illustrations are gorgeous, but the stories lack the shock or suspense and reveals that the original 4 have. They were fun, but they weren't mind blowing.

Still a fun read and will revisit this on Halloween seasons to come. 4 stars!