You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

hongjoongie's profile picture

hongjoongie 's review for:

My Monticello by Jocelyn Nicole Johnson
3.5
dark emotional informative reflective sad tense
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

Everything at the top of that hill felt new to me that morning, transfigured from the times I'd come before, for school trips, for work. Before, there’d always been some measure of distance, a wall between whatever Monticello was and my real life. Real life was Momma, MaViolet, my friends. Real life was school and my determination to do something that mattered. To do something for other people, especially people like the ones l'd grown up with, who were all too often undermined and undervalued. l'd kept real life in one place, and the imagined life of my ancestors in another unexamined place, like a room with no windows. Now my real life flailed and smoked behind me. Now this was my life.
Walking up, I felt myself seesawing again between density and lightness, between Momma’s disavowal of this painful heritage and MaViolet’s cautious regard. 

I loved the ideas and themes explored in these stories and novella, as well as the world building, how they all felt slightly dystopian, and the diverse formats. However, my enjoyment was inconsistent. The standout here is definitely “Control Negro,” and “Virginia is Not Your Home” and “The King of Xandria” are also really good. The titular novella has highs and lows. The beginning and ending were good, but I felt like not enough happened. I wanted the ideas of lineage/legacy and multigenerational trauma and mixed identities and reclamation to be discussed more. And there were too many characters that I didn’t connect with and weren’t developed enough. Overall, I enjoyed this collection, but it could’ve been better.