You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
maxarcreads 's review for:
Phantasma
by Kaylie Smith
This is a 3.75 for me. I think the idea was a really cool idea, I think the writing overall was solid, and the trials were very interesting. In a way each trial reminded me of an escape room challenge.
But I wasn't able to fully connect with the book and that could be a me issue. It just felt at times surface level and never really delving into anything deeper. The challenges while interesting never truly felt nitty, gritty or scary. While there were bloody moments with the trials, they just felt like they were completed way too fast for me to become invested in what was happening.
The same could be said for the mission to help Blackwell. At times it just felt like an afterthought like oh yea I am supposed to find a way to help this guy escape and really all it involved was looking around in this creepy manor for no rhyme or reason. Just looking for anything that didn't look like it fit. I thought there would be clues or something that would add to the challenge like blackwell leaving clues behind as he has been at this for centuries with moments of gained clarity. Like when they were talking about Frankenstein in the library, I thought this would be a clue that would lead to another clue and then another. But nope just talk of going into rooms to look around with no luck. Also being done when there are supposedly ghouls and other beings or illusions out to hurt you but never really show up to deter you from your task.
I will say that I enjoyed the spicy chemistry between Blackwell and Ophelia, but I didn't believe the romance. They just felt like really buddies who had good spicy times. There was just no deeper connection that made me think that if they ever made it out of this situation alive that they would even stay in touch.
As individuals I did find Ophelia to be a complex character who I didn't like. Sometimes she just unkind to people for no reason but considering how she has never really been around other people or put into social situations and given the manor where anyone could backstab you, I guess I got the reason why but at times it felt like she was just kicking people when they were down when they were just trying to connect in a horrible situation. Blackwell was interesting at times but because he didn't know much about himself it's not like we could get to know him and become invested in him, but his actions and attitude did make him enjoyable when he was on page.
Overall, the story did entertain me, but it was not a story or set of characters that I became super invested in.
I did receive an ARC copy in exchange for an honest review.
But I wasn't able to fully connect with the book and that could be a me issue. It just felt at times surface level and never really delving into anything deeper. The challenges while interesting never truly felt nitty, gritty or scary. While there were bloody moments with the trials, they just felt like they were completed way too fast for me to become invested in what was happening.
The same could be said for the mission to help Blackwell. At times it just felt like an afterthought like oh yea I am supposed to find a way to help this guy escape and really all it involved was looking around in this creepy manor for no rhyme or reason. Just looking for anything that didn't look like it fit. I thought there would be clues or something that would add to the challenge like blackwell leaving clues behind as he has been at this for centuries with moments of gained clarity. Like when they were talking about Frankenstein in the library, I thought this would be a clue that would lead to another clue and then another. But nope just talk of going into rooms to look around with no luck. Also being done when there are supposedly ghouls and other beings or illusions out to hurt you but never really show up to deter you from your task.
I will say that I enjoyed the spicy chemistry between Blackwell and Ophelia, but I didn't believe the romance. They just felt like really buddies who had good spicy times. There was just no deeper connection that made me think that if they ever made it out of this situation alive that they would even stay in touch.
As individuals I did find Ophelia to be a complex character who I didn't like. Sometimes she just unkind to people for no reason but considering how she has never really been around other people or put into social situations and given the manor where anyone could backstab you, I guess I got the reason why but at times it felt like she was just kicking people when they were down when they were just trying to connect in a horrible situation. Blackwell was interesting at times but because he didn't know much about himself it's not like we could get to know him and become invested in him, but his actions and attitude did make him enjoyable when he was on page.
Overall, the story did entertain me, but it was not a story or set of characters that I became super invested in.
I did receive an ARC copy in exchange for an honest review.