I find it rare that marketing comparisons on books are actually accurate but “phantom of the opera” x “moulin rouge” really is a good way to describe the overall tone of this book. And as a major fan of those two for both their classic stories and musical goodness, I am ecstatic to report that this did somewhat live up to the vibe that I was expecting, my problem was just that the plot and characters weren't interesting enough to hold my attention.

I did have some mixed feelings starting this because of the number of mixed reviews I came across but it was a pleasant read. It's just unfortunate that I didn't really care for most of the characters (that wasn't the mc) and their relationships, which I find important for a story focused on romance. Nevertheless, it does feature a strong female lead that grew into herself and was a very unique voice.

Kalia is that snarky and sarcastic MC that is quite popular in YA so if you are looking for more of that in a ~not fae~ setting, here you go!

It started off endearing and intriguing but the plot never really sunk in for me. I did like how being a magician and possessing magic is a normal phenomenon in this world. And how the issue was between those who acquired magic in their life and those who were born with it. It was an interesting conversation and kept this book from getting a lower rating from me.

You’re basically thrown into the world with little build up from there so I would not recommend this if you’re looking for in-depth world-building.

If you’re looking for that tall, dark, and handsome male mc that’s always brooding somewhere, you’ll find that here together with the magical carnival vibes. If you liked the concept of Caraval and The Night Circus, together with the mysteries, but you didn’t enjoy the execution, perhaps try this. This felt more magical to me personally as it takes you straight into the world. But I'm not sure I liked any of those enough to fully recommend them either.

I really liked the tone that the writing brought to life. It’s mysterious and adventurous, while still being magical. Even though the characters and the plot were not for me.

↣ It does takes time for the mystery aspect to take part in the plot but if you’re looking for the type of light fantasy filled with drama then you can try this out. ↢

“Make no mistake, I know I don't have to prove a single thing to them. What matters most is what I prove to myself. Giving up would be an insult to everything I know I'm capable of. And I've already come this far.”

— overall thoughts: 3.0 —
⇢ trigger warnings database//

-----------------
PRE READ:
moulin rouge + phantom of the opera ?? I AM SOLD!!!!



the musical person in me is craving