kaylaramoutar's profile picture

kaylaramoutar 's review for:

The Towering Sky by Katharine McGee
3.0

Uggggghhhhhhhhh.

Listen. NOTHING happens in this book until, let's say, 75% in. Truly. There's a lot of recapping - which, tbh, was helpful because some stuff/people I forgot - and a hell of a lot of thinking. In the second book I had started to like some of the characters and some I still liked but others... nah.

Here's some specific and/or vague thoughts on each section:
Leda: Despite obviously not Loving her in the first book I warmed up to her much more in the second one. This one she is also okay, probably the best we've seen her. She's finally coming to terms with what she did and how she can't handle her issues with drugs anymore, and I can see some real strides in her character. (That scene with her dad was good as well.)
Avery: Girl. GIRL. She's a mess. Every single section of hers is a MESS. Stop wanting to fuck your brother!!!! I know he's not your blood-relative but you GREW UP TOGETHER. AS SIBLINGS. That makes it not cool!!! If you'd met at like 16 maybe we can talk! But you grEW UP TOGETHER!!!!
Watt: Boring af. I liked seeing him demolished by the admissions dean.
Rylin: Her entire plotline in this book was about her romance/love-triangle. That's it. A couple of throaway lines about wanting to become a holo-maker was not good enough. Literally every section was about her and her relationship with either Hiral or Cord.
Calliope: Not massively a fan of hers and was super annoyed her story had nothing to do with the overall plot of the novel. I get she had a part to play in the second book but this one she literally was sad/annoyed about having to be a "good" girl and going to secret dates with Brice. Why was she even here? Her storyline took up space/pages and was literally useless to the plot.

The good:
- The characters talked about their issues/problems to other characters, which was a breath of fresh air. I hate when a book leans on miscommunication as the main plot device and thankfully this book didn't do that.
- Avery and Leda's friendship felt nice and I wish there was way more of that and way less of Avery's overthinking about her brother. Also Avery's boyfriend was nice (and I felt bad for him).
- Everything wrapped up nicely at the end and I DO NOT need a spin-off (do you hear me, McGee? Do you? I will not read a story about what you left open at the end. I won't.)
- The reveal on who killed Mariel. That was good. I wish there was more explained, maybe shown, instead of just the two pages it got, but I definitely didn't see it coming.

The bad:
- Avery's whole storyline, as usual
- Calliope's entire existence (and her Annoying As Hell family/step-family, good god I wanted to smack Livya)
- The writing felt weirdly juvenile. I think maybe it was rushed and that made it come across as younger sounding. There was also the problem of the writing telling me what other characters thought. So for example if we're in Leda's section and Watt says something, the text would say "Watt says, obviously meaning that he _____" or whatever. Like maybe have dialogue that tells me what they think instead of constantly saying "[blank] says, clearly thinking ____" Like, stop.

The medium:
- The ending. Was it obvious what happened? Yes. Was it a good ending? I guess?


McGee's next book looks interesting and this trilogy wasn't as terrible as my reviews make it out to be so I'll definitely be looking into it.