I honestly enjoyed this one a lot more than I thought I would. The writing is sharp, witty at times. The characters, at least those of January and Gus, felt layered and detailed. Emily Henry does an excellent job of balancing the darker storylines with humor, making sure you don't get dragged too deep into each character's despair. On a more personal level, I loved that the story was set 'Up North' in Michigan, right on lake Michigan. It reminded me of childhood, and more recent, vacations there.

The story certainly includes a lot of tropes that you would expect to find in a Rom-Com, leading to a pretty predictable plot line. But it was still fun to see it develop, sort of like watching a Rom-Com movie you've seen a dozen times.

There were a few minor aspects of the book that bugged me. Even though January constantly states she has her own problems going on, it still felt as though she was trying to 'fix' Gus in some way. This is a pet peeve of mine with female characters. Also her instance on calling herself 'Dumb bunny' throughout was just...really weird. And reminded me way too much of Zootopia.. So there's that.

But overall, a lighthearted rom-com, touching on darker topics too, perfect for a relaxing day at the beach (or on your couch during Quarantine).

3.5 stars, rounded up

TW: infidelity, cancer, death of a family member, divorce

Thanks to Berkley for the advanced copy in exchange for an honest review!