I didnt hate this but i didnt love it either. Tyler was an interesting character, as was the majority of the supporting characters. There a lot of great reflections about God, Catholicism, how people interpret the Bible and various people'  relationship with God and sin. The family aspect was really well written. I also felt Poppy and Tyler had good chemistry. Definitely insta love which took away from the seriousness of the taboo for me. Majority of this book Poppy came off sus to me. Literally until the end I thought she was playing him for some reason.  I wish this wasn't erotica because all the church similes and catholic references in the sex scenes got annoying quick. I also feel like the sex scenes got in the way of the more interesting ones regarding their relationship with each other and God. I also think this series is very much what a woman thinks men think which is obvious given its a female author but it got quite ridiculous at times.