I could not decide whether or not I was going with 4 or 5 stars throughout a lot of this book... but as I finished that final page I am landing with 4. Don't get me wrong - I still really enjoyed this book and tore through it! But there was just some repetition I could have done without and the end -- let's just say it was from total left field... so far out into left field that I was left wondering the validity of it. BUT... I still never would have totally guessed it... I had a lot of theories and some of them half panned out while others were dead in the water.

The writing definitely pulled me in to the story. I felt like I was there and part of the wedding party. I felt like I was on this dreary, wet island. I just felt it all. I love the setting of this book and the tone. I will definitely be reading more from Lucy Foley!