Take a photo of a barcode or cover
ohiobookgal 's review for:
The Lost Apothecary
by Sarah Penner
I had really high expectations for this book, for the first few weeks I saw nothing but glowing reviews. Then I finally picked it up in April and had to set it aside because it just wasn’t clicking with me. I saw a few mixed reviews and thought yay it isn’t just me! My mood changed and I decided to try again and it was a bit better this time around, but it still fell a bit flat for me.
The writing style is very easy to read and I really loved the idea of the story. I commonly find that I am more drawn to the past timeline in historical fiction, but in this one I did not care for the present one at all. Oh Caroline... I could not connect to her at all. I didn’t understand some of the issues she raised... like why couldn’t she have gone to an Ohio college instead of Cambridge? And she got mad at her books because what good had they done her (exact quote). Ok, sure. Suffice it to say, I didn’t like her.
Enough about not-so-sweet Caroline, back to my review. I enjoyed reading from the POV of both Nella and Eliza. I preferred Nella, but I liked how their stories complemented each other. I also liked their friendship and seeing it blossom in the short amount of time we are shown. I enjoyed learning more about some of the past customers of Nella’s, but wanted more details from them all. I also wanted this to be a darker tone, it felt a bit more like a light fluffy story that just so happened to be about murder.
I know so many people have loved this one, but for me it was just ok. Because I enjoyed the past timeline, it was a 3/5⭐️
The writing style is very easy to read and I really loved the idea of the story. I commonly find that I am more drawn to the past timeline in historical fiction, but in this one I did not care for the present one at all. Oh Caroline... I could not connect to her at all. I didn’t understand some of the issues she raised... like why couldn’t she have gone to an Ohio college instead of Cambridge? And she got mad at her books because what good had they done her (exact quote). Ok, sure. Suffice it to say, I didn’t like her.
Enough about not-so-sweet Caroline, back to my review. I enjoyed reading from the POV of both Nella and Eliza. I preferred Nella, but I liked how their stories complemented each other. I also liked their friendship and seeing it blossom in the short amount of time we are shown. I enjoyed learning more about some of the past customers of Nella’s, but wanted more details from them all. I also wanted this to be a darker tone, it felt a bit more like a light fluffy story that just so happened to be about murder.
I know so many people have loved this one, but for me it was just ok. Because I enjoyed the past timeline, it was a 3/5⭐️