Okay I really enjoyed this...as a fan of historical fiction novels with some splashes of paranormal. Now I am by no means an expert on the horror genre but I would never consider this to be a horror so I can see why the book pitched as "titanic horror story" isn't getting rave reviews. I like all the switching back and fourth between times and boats. I was still left with questions but I got a good idea of all the characters and why they did what they did. I liked it.