Despite how mediocre I found the first three novels in this series and how long it took me to listen to this one, A Question of Holmes is undeniably my favorite installment in said series. While a few aspects did leave something to be desired, I enjoyed this novel immensely.

Unlike its predecessors, Charlotte narrates almost the entire novel. Her blunt, analytical personality was a refreshing contrast to Jamie’s familiar, easygoing nature. I wonder if this change is part of why I liked the story so much.

The combination of the new setting, the intensity of the mystery, and Jamie and Charlotte’s lovely romance had me completely invested. Although I suspected one of the characters almost instantly and ended up being right, the whole story was a lot of fun. I also liked the audiobook narrator; despite her apparently being older than Charlotte, she narrated really well. It added an extra element that only boosted my enjoyment.

Aside from my ability to predict the antagonist, my biggest issue was the ending. I do believe it was realistic and fitting, but I usually don’t like open endings. I’m glad things worked out for Charlotte and Jamie, and I understand more isn’t always better; I simply want more.

I’m glad I didn’t give up on this series, because A Question of Holmes was the greatest novel in it. I look forward to seeing what Cavallaro does next.

Representation:
• Leander, a side character, is queer and actively in an m/m relationship.

CW: death, kidnapping, mention of rape