This was my first Emily Henry, and a reread. I liked most of the book. The characters were good for YA, the situation was interesting, and the writing was beautiful. It had some great moments on grief that really struck me. But then the ending. The first time I read this I was confused, so this time I purposely slowed down…and it still confused me. It just never felt clear enough for me what was happening. And I found the second to last line just pandering as well. But overall it was enjoyable, although I prefer Emily Henry’s adult books more.