Take a photo of a barcode or cover
grogu_djarin 's review for:
The Stone Sky
by N.K. Jemisin
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
reflective
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Overall Thoughts:
While I found this equally as enjoyable as the first two books in the trilogy, I ultimately felt that the answers to all the questions were less satisfying than the questions themselves. The worldbuilding surrounding these answers, centered on the extinct civilization that built the obelisks, Syl Anagist, is deep and imaginative, but it resolved all the sense of mystery and wonder present in the earlier books. The new setting, which feels more like science fiction, is also so different it almost feels like a different book.
That said, the quality of the writing is superb and there is excellent character exploration throughout. I especially liked how thematic parallels were woven through the book, both in the past and present but also in Essun and Nassun's respective character arcs. The trilogy’s central themes of power, oppression, and intergenerational trauma are not only revisited but amplified, and Jemisin skillfully explores how these dynamics existed in the seeming utopia of Syl Anagist, just as they had been explored earlier in the Fulcrum and the Stillness. Essun and Nassun felt like two sides of the same coin, each pursuing similar yet diametrically opposed goals, leading to an inevitable confrontation as the story progresses. Themes of personal choice, and the difficulties in making them, also run parallel for all three characters (Essun, Nassun, and Hoa) and were quite strong.
While I found this equally as enjoyable as the first two books in the trilogy, I ultimately felt that the answers to all the questions were less satisfying than the questions themselves. The worldbuilding surrounding these answers, centered on the extinct civilization that built the obelisks, Syl Anagist, is deep and imaginative, but it resolved all the sense of mystery and wonder present in the earlier books. The new setting, which feels more like science fiction, is also so different it almost feels like a different book.
That said, the quality of the writing is superb and there is excellent character exploration throughout. I especially liked how thematic parallels were woven through the book, both in the past and present but also in Essun and Nassun's respective character arcs. The trilogy’s central themes of power, oppression, and intergenerational trauma are not only revisited but amplified, and Jemisin skillfully explores how these dynamics existed in the seeming utopia of Syl Anagist, just as they had been explored earlier in the Fulcrum and the Stillness. Essun and Nassun felt like two sides of the same coin, each pursuing similar yet diametrically opposed goals, leading to an inevitable confrontation as the story progresses. Themes of personal choice, and the difficulties in making them, also run parallel for all three characters (Essun, Nassun, and Hoa) and were quite strong.
Likes:
- I loved the strong themes and how they were threaded through the story in parallel. This is definitely the most reflective book in the trilogy and made me pause to not just reflect on the world in the story, but also the ways in which our own world can be similar.
- Going back to three perspectives and exploring multiple new locations, after only two perspectives and two locations in The Obelisk Gate, really helped the pacing of the story.
- Syl Anagist was a fascinating society and Jemisin performed some top tier worldbuilding. I was often in awe at some of the things she described.
- While I found Nassun really unlikable in The Obelisk Gate, it feels more fitting here where she serves the story as an almost pseudo-antagonist. I found myself rooting for her as much as I was frustrated by her, but again it was due to Jemisin's skill in depicting a traumatized child trying to navigate a broken world.
- Hoa was always one of my favorite characters, and his character arc remained one of my favorite parts of the book. I loved his childlike innocence at approaching the world and how it contrasted with Nassun's more impulsive, destructive tendencies.
- I can't say more, but I loved the ending.
Dislikes:
- I almost feel like the book explained too much and that I'd have enjoyed it a bit more if a few mysteries had been left dangling.
- While the worldbuilding in Syl Anagist is superb, it's a drastically different setting than what had come before and felt a bit jarring at times since it reads more like a science fiction in a trilogy that had been pretty reliably fantasy.
Other Notes:
- The second person perspective is certainly one of the unique characteristics of this trilogy and you eventually find out why that is in the story and it was a bit neat seeing how it was woven into the narrative.
Would Recommend To:
- If you enjoyed the firsts two book in the trilogy you should read this to see the culmination of the trilogy and to have all the mysteries from the earlier books revealed.
Do Not Recommend To:
- Anyone who hasn't read the first two books in the trilogy: The Fifth Season and The Obelisk Gate. This is the third book in the trilogy, and you'll need to read those two books to understand this.