Not quite a 4 as some of the middle section was a little repetitive - probably could have lost 25-50 pages and not lost anything from the story.

Besides that - generally tightly plotted, tense, and absorbing. I do love that you generally know what you're getting with a Megan Miranda thriller, and this time the small town setting was particularly evocative and effective. I liked the story a lot and Hazel, though not particularly memorable, made for a good general main character for the action to revolve around. Caden and Gage were a little one-dimensional, and the Jamie storyline kind of disappeared once it was resolved - no real closure despite all the build up, which was a little disappointing.

Felt that MM sticked the landing for the overall story better than a number of her other books, but as always, it wraps up just a little too quickly once the main secrets are revealed. 

This had made me want to re-read my first MM book again (The Last To Vanish) as I didn't appreciate the MM style at the time and it also had a very effective and claustrophobic small town with an outsider main character trying to uncover town and family secrets.