lslanker 's review for:

Forgive Me, I Meant to Do It: False Apology Poems by Gail Carson Levine, Matthew Cordell
5.0

Forgive Me, I Meant to Do It is a book of illustrated poetry that reminded me of my Shel Silverstein days, where I would take his book of poems and laugh out loud to myself as I read through his words and looked at his descriptive pictures. Gail Carson Levine and Matthew Cordell have managed to channel Silverstein in their own way in their book of poetry. The poems are all in the same style; a style that William Carlos William created in his poem "This is Just to Say" (with whom Levine shares a birthday!). Since all poems in the book are titled the same name, the very informative table of contents lists all of the poems as "This is Just to Say" with various page numbers. Levine also places her introduction several pages into her book (much to the chagrin of her editor!) and includes a page of background information in what seems is a random place in the book.

Overall, the poems in the book are funny and many of them made me literally "lol". Many of them are based on fairy tales, such as one that describes Red Riding Hood's grandmother running away so that at least one of them can live. There were a couple of poems that I didn't understand, which may be because I'm not familiar with the fairy tale they're referring to. The artwork is simple and sketch-like, similar to Shel Silverstein. The pictures add a lot to the poems, and sometimes I did not really understand the poem until I saw the picture. I would use this book to show alternate perspectives for fairy tales and also as examples of irony and sarcasm in writing. It would be perfect for an upper elementary classroom, but could be used with older grades as an example of how to write funny poems. This book was a 2012 notable poetry book, which is where I found the title.